| NONCONFERENCE RECORDS |
| Each league's record against out-of-league competition |
| W | L | Pct. |
| Metropolitan | 99 | 22 | .818 |
| Hoosier Hills | 86 | 26 | .768 |
| Northland | 49 | 21 | .700 |
| Northern Lakes | 81 | 36 | .692 |
| Tri-Eastern | 70 | 32 | .686 |
| Sagamore | 69 | 32 | .683 |
| Duneland | 36 | 18 | .667 |
| Mid-State | 75 | 39 | .658 |
| Southwestern Indiana | 52 | 28 | .650 |
| North Central | 76 | 41 | .650 |
| Blue Chip | 77 | 43 | .642 |
| Southern | 62 | 35 | .639 |
| Mid-Indiana | 68 | 42 | .618 |
| Allen County | 59 | 43 | .578 |
| Olympic | 42 | 32 | .568 |
| Pocket | 65 | 53 | .551 |
| Northern Indiana | 62 | 53 | .539 |
| Hoosier | 57 | 50 | .533 |
| Northwest Crossroads | 54 | 48 | .529 |
| Mid-Hoosier | 58 | 53 | .523 |
| Northeast Hoosier | 59 | 54 | .522 |
| Great Lakes Athletic | 30 | 28 | .517 |
| Ohio River Valley | 45 | 43 | .511 |
| Eastern Indiana | 31 | 31 | .500 |
| Porter County | 44 | 44 | .500 |
| Mid-Southern | 57 | 59 | .491 |
| Hoosier Heritage | 51 | 54 | .486 |
| Summit | 54 | 58 | .482 |
| Southern Indiana | 43 | 47 | .478 |
| Hoosier Crossroads | 55 | 61 | .474 |
| Three Rivers | 46 | 52 | .469 |
| Central Indiana | 51 | 60 | .459 |
| West Central | 44 | 52 | .458 |
| Big Eight | 51 | 64 | .443 |
| Conference Indiana | 48 | 65 | .425 |
| Patoka Lake | 44 | 60 | .423 |
| White River | 36 | 53 | .404 |
| Hoosier Heartland | 39 | 60 | .394 |
| Mid-Eastern | 38 | 62 | .380 |
| Tri-River | 34 | 57 | .374 |
| Western Indiana | 34 | 58 | .370 |
| Northwestern | 20 | 35 | .364 |
| Wabash River | 30 | 54 | .357 |
| Midwest | 35 | 64 | .354 |
| Northern State | 34 | 63 | .351 |
| Northeast Corner | 33 | 65 | .337 |
| Indiana Crossroads | 19 | 38 | .333 |
| Indianapolis | 30 | 65 | .316 |
| Greater South Shore | 27 | 70 | .278 |
| Midland | 13 | 34 | .277 |